President Donald Trump's $10 billion defamation lawsuit against the BBC has taken an unexpected turn, with his attorneys now fighting to prevent former special counsel Jack Smith from testifying about Trump's actions surrounding the January 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol.

The BBC subpoenaed Smith as part of its defense against Trump's lawsuit, which accuses the British broadcaster of deceptively editing his January 6 speech in a 2024 documentary.

Smith, who investigated Trump's attempts to overturn the 2020 presidential election, reportedly has no objection to testifying. Trump's lawyers, however, argue that Smith lacks firsthand knowledge of the speech or Trump's intentions.

Trump Wants Billions but Resists Questioning

The dispute extends beyond Smith.

Trump's attorneys have also resisted efforts to question the president himself. Trump was scheduled to give a deposition on October 16 but canceled, citing matters of national importance.

His lawyers subsequently proposed delaying the deposition until January 2027, after the December deadline for gathering evidence.

The BBC has asked a federal judge to compel Trump to testify, arguing that the president cannot pursue billions in damages while preventing the defendant from obtaining evidence necessary to defend itself.

A federal magistrate judge has warned that continued failure to comply with court orders could result in sanctions.

Jack Smith's Evidence Could Be Significant

Smith's investigation examined Trump's efforts to overturn the 2020 election and his conduct before and during the Capitol attack.

The BBC argues that evidence gathered during that investigation could help establish what Trump knew about the potential for violence and whether his actions contributed to the events of January 6.

Trump's attorneys counter that Smith was not involved in preparing the speech and that his knowledge comes from evidence collected during his investigation rather than personal observation.

The BBC maintains that those arguments do not justify preventing his deposition.

The BBC Acknowledged Its Editing Mistake

The original controversy began when a BBC documentary combined separate portions of Trump's January 6 speech, creating the impression that he directly encouraged supporters to engage in violence.

The BBC acknowledged that the editing was misleading and apologized. However, it denies that the documentary legally defamed Trump.

The broadcaster is also challenging whether Trump can demonstrate the reputational harm necessary to support his claims.

The Lawsuit Remains Unresolved

Trump initiated the lawsuit seeking $10 billion in damages. But the resulting discovery process has opened his own conduct, communications, and financial claims to examination.

His lawyers are now contesting requests for testimony and evidence that the BBC considers essential to its defense.

Whether Smith will ultimately testify, and when Trump will submit to questioning, remains unresolved.

For now, the legal dispute presents an unusual situation: The president is demanding billions of dollars over coverage of January 6 while fighting attempts to examine the evidence surrounding that very event.

Sources: The New Republic, October 19, 2026; Associated Press, October 15, 2026; TheWrap, October 19, 2026.