A Republican election official in Georgia set out to uncover potential voter fraud. Instead, his investigation produced an embarrassing discovery: four voters identified as dead were very much alive.
The incident, uncovered by ProPublica, highlights the dangers of relying on questionable software and unverified allegations to challenge legitimate voters.
It also raises troubling questions about the election integrity movement's continued efforts to identify widespread fraud despite repeated failures to substantiate its claims.
The Dead Voters Who Weren't Dead
Max Clavijo, a Republican member of the Forsyth County Board of Voter Registrations and Elections, questioned the eligibility of 69 voters following the November 2026 midterm elections.
His allegations relied partly on information generated by ELLY's Election Monitor, software promoted by individuals associated with the conservative Election Integrity Network.
Among the supposed irregularities were four voters identified as deceased.
There was just one problem.
All four were alive.
ProPublica reporters independently located the individuals, demonstrating that the software had incorrectly flagged legitimate voters.
The findings undermined the reliability of the information being used to question election records.
Thousands of Voters Under Suspicion
The problems extended beyond the four supposedly deceased voters.
Clavijo also questioned more than 22,000 names appearing on county voter rolls.
Among the 69 voters whose eligibility he specifically disputed, 38 were flagged because their registrations contained initials rather than complete first names.
Several of those voters explained that using initials was simply their normal practice.
There was no established evidence that these registrations represented fraudulent votes.
Nevertheless, the software's findings became the basis for questioning whether legitimate voters belonged on the rolls.
Election Fraud Claims Meet Reality
The software was developed by Rick Richards, a member of the Election Integrity Network, an organization associated with conservative activist Cleta Mitchell.
The network has encouraged citizen involvement in identifying suspected election irregularities, particularly following Donald Trump's false claims that the 2020 presidential election was stolen.
Critics argue that poorly verified voter challenges can intimidate eligible voters, burden election administrators, and undermine public confidence.
The Forsyth County election board ultimately rejected Clavijo's attempted challenges.
Clavijo maintained that his objective was to improve voter-roll accuracy rather than interfere with election certification. He also acknowledged that he could not guarantee the accuracy of the information.
The Problem With Unverified Accusations
Election officials have legitimate responsibilities to maintain accurate voter rolls and investigate credible allegations of fraud.
But identifying a voter as deceased is a serious allegation that requires reliable evidence.
Incorrectly matching names, relying on outdated records, or treating incomplete registration information as suspicious can produce false accusations against eligible Americans.
In Forsyth County, the errors were not hypothetical.
Four living people were classified as dead.
Dozens of other voters faced questions over registration details that did not establish wrongdoing.
An Embarrassing Result
The investigation produced no demonstrated evidence that the four voters had committed fraud.
Instead, it exposed significant weaknesses in the information being used to question their eligibility.
For a political movement that has repeatedly warned Americans about supposedly fraudulent elections, the episode offers an uncomfortable lesson.
Accusations are not evidence.
And a computer program identifying someone as dead does not make them dead.
